Is communism fundamentally incompatible with democracy?
Posted by T.Collins Logan on
Here are some democratic (or, better yet, consensus-driven) communist mass societies:
1. Free Territory of Ukraine
(1918 - 1921)
2. Rojava (in Northern Syria)
(2012 - Present)
3. Revolutionary Catalonia
(1936–1939)
4. Korean People's Association in Manchuria
(1929–1931)
5. Morelos Commune
(1913 - 1917)
You will find other examples here: List of anarchist communities
Now one could nit-pick that these aren’t nation states…but they are certainly self-contained autonomous regions, some of which being quite large. One could also argue that many didn’t endure for very long — but that wasn’t a consequence of any inherent lack of viability, but instead most often the result of violent, authoritarian rulers who didn’t want them to exist. So either argument would be splitting hairs IMO.
In any case, these and many other examples throughout history (such as the Paris Commune, which Marx himself admired) demonstrate that communism (and socialist anarchism) are not incompatible with democracy…at all.
My 2 cents.
1. Free Territory of Ukraine
(1918 - 1921)
2. Rojava (in Northern Syria)
(2012 - Present)
3. Revolutionary Catalonia
(1936–1939)
4. Korean People's Association in Manchuria
(1929–1931)
5. Morelos Commune
(1913 - 1917)
You will find other examples here: List of anarchist communities
Now one could nit-pick that these aren’t nation states…but they are certainly self-contained autonomous regions, some of which being quite large. One could also argue that many didn’t endure for very long — but that wasn’t a consequence of any inherent lack of viability, but instead most often the result of violent, authoritarian rulers who didn’t want them to exist. So either argument would be splitting hairs IMO.
In any case, these and many other examples throughout history (such as the Paris Commune, which Marx himself admired) demonstrate that communism (and socialist anarchism) are not incompatible with democracy…at all.
My 2 cents.
Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entryThis link is not meant to be clicked. It contains the trackback URI for this entry. You can use this URI to send ping- & trackbacks from your own blog to this entry. To copy the link, right click and select "Copy Shortcut" in Internet Explorer or "Copy Link Location" in Mozilla.
No Trackbacks
The author does not allow comments to this entry
Comments
Display comments as Linear | ThreadedNo comments